Cutco vs. Wusthof Knives – Who Reigns Supreme?

kitchen knive

In the market of quality kitchen knives, German-based brands of knives reign supreme, but that does not mean they don’t face intense competition from their American-based counterparts. Indeed, the German company, Wusthof, is one of the most popular brands.

On the other hand, the Cutco knife brand has been proudly producing American-made knives for several decades. Let’s go on a deep comparison of Cutco vs. Wusthof to see which company is superior.

Are Wusthof Knives Worth the Money?

Yes, Wusthof knives are definitely worth the money. Wusthof has a solid reputation, and their knives give enormous value. In terms of quality, construction, and design, Wusthof knives are second to none. Their precision blades are crafted from high-quality steel and offer exceptional sharpness and durability. Furthermore, their sleek and stylish designs will complement any kitchen.

Are Cutco Kitchen Knives of Good Quality?

Yes, Cutco Kitchen Knives offer good value. For more than 50 years, Cutco has produced high-quality knives. Their knives are known for precision, durability, and ease of use. Nonetheless, you can find a high-quality forged knife from brands like Wusthof or Zwilling for a similar price or less, not to mention numerous designs.

Some Background

Besides the differences in their products, these companies also had very different beginnings. Let’s take a deeper look at how they started compared to where they are now.

Wusthof

Wusthof is based in Solingen, Germany, and is known as the “City of Blades” since it is home to many other knife brands. It was founded in 1814, and since then, the brand has made a name for itself for producing quality knives made from top German stainless steel and excellent craftsmanship.

Wusthof continues its successful endeavors globally by developing knives with modern features that address the needs of its ever-expanding customers. For this reason, renowned culinary professionals such as Gordon Ramsey have chosen to praise Wusthof knife block sets and use them in their restaurants.

Buy Wusthof Knives on Amazon

Video Credit: YouTube

Wusthof includes several different knife lines with various designs; each line serves a purpose. The collections under the Wusthof brand are the Amici and Amici 1814, Aeon, Ikon, Crafter, Gourmet, Performer and Wusthof classic knife set.

A Wusthof knife comes with a long-established quality. By purchasing such a knife, you are guaranteed to get a durable knife with a blade that retains its edge. Moreover, the company offers many knives and knife sets that will please even the people with the highest expectations.

Cutco

Cutco prides itself on being a small-town and family-owned business based in Olean, New York. The company puts its American values front and center, providing jobs that support many American families. Created by ALCOA, Cutco started becoming the company it is today in 1982, later expanding its operations nationwide and in Canada. In 2019, Cutco celebrated its 70th anniversary.

Buy Wusthof Knives on Amazon

Video Credit: YouTube

Another thing that the company is exceptionally proud of is that it has been manufacturing Cutco knives exclusively in the United States for decades, offering high-quality products. The company states that it is the largest manufacturer of kitchen cutlery in North America.

Cutco’s collections of knife sets are Homemaker, Galley, Studio, Essentials, and more.

Comparison

A more direct comparison of the two brands will make it easier to determine which one is the better choice.

Blade

Cutco knives come in three different styles of blades, Double-D edge, Straight edge, and Santoku. Knives with the Double-D edge have serrated-like blades, perfect for cutting slippery types of surfaces, such as bread.

Straight-edged knives are closer to typical chef’s knives. A knife with this blade might need more frequent sharpening, but it can be sharpened at home, unlike the Double-D edge. Santoku-edged knives are based on the popular Santoku style that many other companies include in their sets. Moreover, all the blades on Cutco knives are stamped.

Wusthof offers more blade options than Cutco knives do, seven different ones, to be exact. However, several of those are very similar to each other. While most of its blades are forged, one laser-cut stamped Wusthof knife is also available.

Manufacturing Process

As mentioned earlier, all Cutco knives are stamped, which means laser-cut from steel sheets. The brand has advanced its crafting processes and ensures top-quality products.

On the other hand, Wusthof has mainly forged knife options and only one stamped blade. A forged knife goes through several steps and is made from a single piece of stainless steel. The forging method is usually preferred because it increases the strength of the knives and allows for sharper edges and durability.

Even though differences between stamped and forged knives would not be immediately apparent to a non-expert, they would slowly become evident with use and time, as forged knives last much longer.

Wusthof mainly offers knives made through highly-praised techniques and top-quality steel. Cutco offers more regular quality knives, indicating that customers might prefer the German brand.

Handle

Cutco knives come with ergonomic handles that make for a comfortable grip. They are designed so the user will not get fatigued while using the knife. Cutco uses thermo-resin to create its handles. All of its knives come with the same style of handle.

Wusthof has a variety of handle styles for different knives. Some knives come with handles made with polyoxymethylene, while others are made from natural wood. Wusthof also creates an ergonomic design, and the materials used for its handles are both natural and synthetic.

Price

Both Cutco knives and Wusthof knives are similarly priced. Both brands stand higher on the top regarding the standard market price. This is because customers are expected to get what they pay for, meaning that buying from these brands guarantees them a quality product that will last long.

However, since Wusthof has more variety as a brand and uses premium techniques to create its knives, it would make more sense to buy from Wusthof.

Warranty

Cutco’s Forever Guarantee is a great feature that offers sharpening (for a small fee) and free replacement at any point in time, no matter when it purchased the knife or if it is even second-hand. This unlimited feature shows that the company is very confident about the quality of its products. Of course, this warranty is valid as long you use the blades as intended. They also require no receipts.

Wusthof offers a lifetime warranty for their knives. However, this only covers manufacturing defects. It is guaranteed to be defect-free when you buy a Wusthof knife. Like Cutco, Wusthof’s warranty is valid if the product is used as intended. Wusthof offers sharpening services for a fee as well.

Best Item From Each Brand

Wüsthof Classic 15-Piece Knife Block Set

wüsthof classic 15 piece knife block set

Buy: Wüsthof Classic 15-Piece Knife Block Set at Amazon

This knife set includes all the top-quality knives you will ever need. Wusthof’s classic blades are made from high carbon stainless steel. These knives are highly durable; they last for many years and can be used in several ways, simplifying every cooking task.

The knives included in this set are hand-honed and retain their intense sharpness because they are made with carbon steel. Honing steel is also provided to sharpen as needed. However, it is recommended that a knife should not need to be sharpened more than once per year with regular use and occasional honing.

The set includes a paring knife, a 4 1/2″ utility knife, a 6″ utility knife, a chef’s knife, a santoku knife, six steak knives, a bread knife, honing steel, and pull-apart shears, all stored within an acacia wood block.

Picture from Williams-Sonoma.com

  • Full tang triple-riveted synthetic polypropylene handles resist fading, discoloration, heat, and impact.
  • Made with Wusthof’s Precision Edge Technology (PEtec) that ensures a 20% sharper blade with twice the edge retention than previous models
  • Resist corrosion and dulling and comes with a limited lifetime warranty

Cutco 21 Piece Kitchen Knife Set

cutco 21 piece kitchen knife set

Buy: Cutco 21 Piece Kitchen Knife Set at Amazon

This Cutco knife set includes one of the company’s three razor-sharp edges, the Double-D recessed edge. The edge allows the blade to cut in multiple ways easily. Its pointed teeth protect it from dulling the knife through contact with the surface.

The hard blades have balance, flexibility, rust and stain resistance, and edge retention. Handle molding incorporates an ergonomic thermo-resin handle design that fits all hands.

The two-piece handle is riveted to the blade with high-quality nickel-silver alloy rivets. Rivets are sanded flush with the handle surface for a comfortable grip. Cutco offers a forever performance guarantee for all their knives.

This set includes a paring knife, a santoku-style trimmer, a santoku-style carver, a santoku-style slicer, a traditional cheese knife, a gourmet prep knife, a tuning fork, and super shears, a vegetable peeler, eight table knives, sharpener, all within a cherry finish oak block.

Picture from Amazon.com

  • 440A high-carbon stainless steel with a full tang design, triple-rivet, and thermo-resin ergonomic handles
  • The Forever Guarantee backs all Cutco knives

Buy Wusthof Knives on Amazon

Which Brand Is Better?

Both Cutco and Wusthof offer top-quality knives and are famous for their craftsmanship. Generally, the customer reviews for both brands indicate that customers keep selecting these companies because they trust that they will be able to purchase products that will last them for years, are durable, and are as sharp as a knife.

Concerning warranty, Cutco offers a much more superior feature with its knives thanks to the Forever Guarantee. Cutco will replace your knife no matter when you purchased it, even if it is after a whole decade. In some cases, you could even get it replaced by Cutco if you were gifted the knife or passed it down to you. Moreover, Cutco will not require any receipts from you.

This is different from Wusthof, which offers a lifetime warranty but only for defects that occur from manufacturing. Cutco does cover manufacturing defects, but its warranty goes beyond that. They will not replace your knife if something happens to it during use or if the issue is not related to a primary defect. Therefore, Cutco’s warranty is superior, showing how much the company believes in the quality of its products.

Regarding craftsmanship, both companies have had the chance to perfect their manufacturing processes because they have been active for several decades in the kitchenware market. Both have been able to make a name for themselves due to the quality they provide.

However, Wusthof’s processes are more highly regarded. Wusthof offers mainly forged knives, the technique that creates the most durable blades, and only one stamped knife. It also uses world-renowned German steel. Cutco solely offers stamped knives, considered inferior while still solid compared to forged knives. Therefore in terms of manufacturing technique, Wusthof is the clear winner.

Besides quality, another thing that is very important to customers is variety. Many of Wusthof’s blades are similar but still provide different features. Cutco offers three types of blades for its knives, while Wusthof provides seven.

Moreover, Cutco produces only one type of handle for its knives, made from synthetic materials, but Wusthof offers several natural and synthetic materials. Once again, Wusthof is the winner, as a more significant offer of selection is something essential for most customers today.

Finally, regarding the price, both companies’ products cost about the same. Of course, both brands are considered more premium, so their price points are generally higher. However, when someone has to choose between Wusthof and Cutco and is ready to spend a certain amount of money, selecting the brand that provides them with the most features would make sense.

While Cutco’s warranty is very appealing, it is not enough to fully win over customers since buying from both brands means that you are ensured a certain level of quality. Therefore, after comparing Cutco vs. Wusthof, and according to everything detailed above, Wusthof is the superior option.


Bestseller No. 1
Cutco 19 Pc Kitchen Knife Set Cherry Wood Stand
Cutco 19 Pc Kitchen Knife Set Cherry Wood Stand
19 Pc. Kitchen Knife Set Includes; 3″ Gourmet Paring Knife; Santoku-Style Trimmer; 7″ Santoku
$1,408.88
Bestseller No. 2
Cutco 21 Piece Kitchen Knife Set with Cherry Finish Oak Block, 8 Table Knives, Paring Knife, Trimmers, Santoku Chopper Chef Knife, Carver, Slicer, Cheese Knife, Turning Fork, Shears, Peeler, Sharpener
Cutco 21 Piece Kitchen Knife Set with Cherry Finish Oak Block, 8 Table Knives, Paring Knife, Trimmers, Santoku Chopper Chef Knife, Carver, Slicer, Cheese Knife, Turning Fork, Shears, Peeler, Sharpener
America’s #1 Brand in Quality Cutlery for Over 50 Years; American Made Products, Manufactured Entirely in the USA by American Craftsmen
$1,649.88
Bestseller No. 3
Four (4) Cutco Classic, Dark Brown Table Steak Knives #1759- Manufacturer Sealed
Four (4) Cutco Classic, Dark Brown Table Steak Knives #1759- Manufacturer Sealed
CUTCO Forever Guarantee provides for free sharpening and replacement forever.; Manufactured in the USA by American craftworkers
$172.49
Bestseller No. 4
CUTCO Set of 4 Steak/Table Knives #1759 - Classic Black
CUTCO Set of 4 Steak/Table Knives #1759 – Classic Black
Cutco’s best-selling knife.; This knife does it all at mealtime, whether it’s a special occasion or an everyday meal.
$172.66
Bestseller No. 6
CUTCO 4 Piece Specialty Knife Set Including Traditional Cheese Knife (1764), 6.25 in Hardy Slicer (3738) and 5 in Petite Santoku with Sheath(2166)
CUTCO 4 Piece Specialty Knife Set Including Traditional Cheese Knife (1764), 6.25 in Hardy Slicer (3738) and 5 in Petite Santoku with Sheath(2166)
These Very Sharp Knives Are Made From 440A High-Carbon, Stainless Steel; Ergonomic Handles Are Composed of Highly Engineered Thermo-resin
$645.00

John Siracusa

Cooking, for me, has always been an "art" infused with traditions. My career was inspired by Hell's Kitchen, the West Side of Manhattan, which boasts one of N.Y. City's best independent restaurant communities, along with Gordon Ramsay's no-nonsense approach towards always being your best.

Recent Posts